Critics
love "The Faithful Spy":
Booklist (starred review):
"Berenson works against the inherent sensationalism of his story with a
diversity of viewpoints and deft character sketches that avoid oversimplifying
the complex beliefs and strategies of his combatants... The plotting is superlative,
baffling readers and characters alike as the mastermind behind al-Qaeda's sleeper
network wages covert war against a vigilant and resourceful enemy. As with Thomas
Harris' Black Sunday (1975) or Joseph Finder's Zero Hour (1996), one could hardly
ask for a more skillful, timely, and well-rounded translation of our worst fears
into satisfying thrills; a sure bet for fans of Jack Higgins and Vince Flynn."
The
New York Times:
''Nam. Nam. Nam. Nam. Nam. Nam.'' The single syllable ricochets like a stray sharp rock through Alex Berenson's ''Faithful Spy,'' connecting fighters and bureaucrats, revolutionaries and black-marketeers, the peaceful and the violent. Though much of the action is conducted by misguided Americans in a hopelessly escalating war, we aren't in Indochina anymore. The word means yes in Arabic, and there is global terror afoot in the novel, with precious few equipped to keep annihilation from our own shores.
The kind of spy thriller Mr. Berenson has set out to deliver has to contend nowadays with a world's worth of violent events flashing from battlefield and bomb site to television or computer screen at the blink of a satellite signal. Where does that leave the war novel? The fiction of international intrigue?
For Mr. Berenson, a reporter for The New York Times who covered Iraq for three months in 2003, it goes beyond ripping his story from the headlines to imagining, and in some instances eerily predicting, scenarios tied to his central premise: that a Central Intelligence Agency operative infiltrated Al Qaeda several years before 9/11. John Wells, his man undercover, is making it his mission to help lasso the storm of
catastrophe, madness, secrets and betrayal that continue in its aftermath...
Mr. Berenson gives Wells -- or Jalal, as he's known in his jihadi incarnation-- a Muslim Lebanese grandmother to make his increasing belief in Islam credible, and a pretty C.I.A. handler, Jennifer Exley, who has also forfeited everything for an ungrateful agency, to doubt and love him simultaneously. When Wells gets wind of a plot against the United States far graver than the World Trade Center attacks, he has to expedite his return to the States to avert it. He comes down from his alien mountains and into post-9/11 American culture like Rip van Winkle in a turban...
Simply, everything and everyone have changed. Wells ''regretted not having been a spy during the cold war,'' Mr. Berenson writes at one point. ''Back then the game had possessed a certain formal elegance. Neither side really expected the other to blow up the world, and proxy soldiers in Africa and Central America fought the nastiest battles.''
Now his Americans step over every conceivable line drawn by the Constitution in scenes of torture and coercion, while their enemies delight in doing the innocent harm. A new language is spoken, couched in hypotheticals and unfamiliar signs, and a new math has had to be devised to calculate the outcome of hijackings, biological assaults and technological cruelty in the service of fundamentalist religion.
If Mr. Berenson remains as much reporter as novelist at this point -- a newspaper editor would tell him he had overstuffed his lead, and that he often tended to impart information that was all too well known -- he still has an ingenious narrative to show for it. Uncertain times call for tough examinations, and ''The Faithful Spy'' doesn't back away.
USA
Today:
The author: Berenson, a New York Times reporter, used his experiences covering the Iraq war to write this unsettling first novel that imagines the life of fictional CIA agent John Wells, who infiltrates al-Qaeda.
The plot: Wells, known to his Muslim compatriots as Jalal, has been a part of the terrorist group for two years when 9/11 strikes. No longer trusted by his handlers in Washington and constantly having to prove himself to his al-Qaeda brothers, Wells is offered the ultimate test of loyalty when terrrorist mastermind Omar Khadri orders the agent to return to the USA and await a new assignment.
What's good: Dirty bombs and biological contamination riddle this novel with paranoia and the frightening realization that an attack on the USA, as it's laid out in The Faithful Spy, appears highly plausible, even inevitable.
The
St. Louis Post-Dispatch:
Back in 2003, The New York Times dispatched reporter Alex Berenson to Iraq
for a three-month stint with the Army. That experience planted the seed
of "The Faithful Spy," Berenson's first novel -- a hold-your-breath
thriller. The plot: Against all odds, CIA agent John Wells has penetrated
al-Qaida, even campaigning against the U.S. invasion of Afghanistan. But
he faces a double burden: Because he's an American, the terrorists don't
fully trust him -- and because he has converted to Islam and spent so much
time abroad in the company of bad people, the CIA no longer fully trusts
him, either.
As
the book unfolds, al-Qaida has some ugly plans for more terror
attacks in the United States -- truck bombs, of course, but
also biological terror and even a "dirty bomb," a
radiological weapon of mass destruction. Wells plays a key
role in the terror plot. But on whose side is he?
Reporter Berenson does well with the technical stuff: how to brew plague germs, uild truck bombs and plot a radiological attack. His CIA overlooks the niceties of international law when it comes to interrogating suspects.
His
al-Qaida terrorists overlook niceties entirely. And against
all odds, Berenson has set aside the stuffy, just-the-facts-Ma'am
prose style of The New York Times. "The Faithful Spy" reads
like, well, like a novel, one that's a grabber.
The
Baltimore Sun:
Though almost five years have passed since the Sept. 11 attacks - a seeming
eternity in an age of 24-hour news cycles and endless permutations and
tribulations that constitute the Iraq war - many still beat the drum that
it's "too soon" to explore the landscape of a post-Sept. 11 world.
It's a mantra, thankfully, that hasn't stopped many literary and commercial
fiction writers from grappling with the concept, even if there have been
few standout efforts so far, and future titles (such as John Updike's
Terrorist and Martin Amis' short story collection starring hijacker Mohamed Atta) sound vaguely squirm-inducing.
Alex Berenson, a business reporter for The New York Times who reported on the war in Iraq in 2003, may have been told he was taking a serious literary risk by using the after-effects of Sept. 11 for his debut thriller. But if so, it's to our benefit that he's ignored those phantom critics and concentrated on building suspense, maintaining thrills and plotting a frighteningly plausible scenario. Save for a few rough patches in believability and pacing, this is a worthwhile first effort...
The Faithful Spy brims with knowledge, especially about the frightening tactics used in the name of war. The bombing scenes are startling for their visceral quality, and Berenson depicts the interrogation of a suspected al-Qaida terrorist but wisely allows his characters to make their own judgments for and against the procedures followed (or bent). But where the author shines most is in showing how a decade of isolation has affected Wells so much that he's alienated from his family and future, and that
fighting in a war that's difficult to win may be for the greater good - but can be a personal disaster.
military.com:
N.Y. Times reporter Berenson's first novel is a pulse-pounding, intelligent thriller that starkly reminds us what's at stake in the war on terrorism or more appropriately, the terrorists' war against America.
CIA agent John Wells is the only agent to ever penetrate al-Qaeda, but he's been out in the cold so long that the Agency brass have begun to question his loyalty. His only ally within the Agency is Jen Exley, his case officer, and even she encourages him to come in.
But, Wells is on to an al-Qaeda plot to attack America again and knows that the Agency will sideline him if he comes in. The plan, which combines a dirty bomb in Times Square and a parallel plot to spread a deadly strain of the plague, is a nightmare scenario that seems all too plausible.
Berenson keeps the plot racing ahead as the action moves from Pakistan to Afghanistan, Diego Garcia, Los Angeles, Atlanta, Montreal, and the Big Apple Ground Zero in the jihadis' wet dreams. The characters sometimes lean toward stereotypical, but the premise is intriguing, the details chillingly authentic, and the action vivid. Berenson shows that he knows how to put the thrill in thriller in an auspicious debut.
The
Washington Post:
Let's give New York Times reporter Alex Berenson credit for the year's most
surefire thriller plot: CIA agent infiltrates al-Qaeda. It's such a sky-high
concept that the film rights were auctioned off months ago, and Keanu Reeves
may play undercover agent John Wells. If the idea is an inspired one in
terms of commercial fiction, Berenson's execution of it is less so, but "The Faithful Spy" offers
a well-informed, often chilling look at how al-Qaeda might launch a major
new attack in the United States -- and how one intrepid undercover agent
might do his darnedest to foil it...
Berenson is very good on all the things you would expect a skilled reporter to be good on... his novel remains a timely reminder of the extremely precarious way we live now.
The
Denver Rocky Mountain News (grade: A-):
"There hasn't been a fictionalized account of the intelligence war against
al Qaeda until now. When you think of the hundreds of Cold War novels produced,
it seems strange that it's taken so long. Happily, New York Times reporter Alex
Berenson has successfully launched a new sub-genre, no-doubt the subject of many
future books... Berenson has done a sharp job of pulling together possible what-
ifs and combining them with a journalist's knowledge of how government and the
military operate... He's already left (Tom) Clancy in the dust."
Kirkus Reviews (starred review):
"A thriller worthy of le Carré... The payoff is tremendous, and there
are standout episodes that hint that the fundamentalists know how to work American
decadence as when one terrorist recruits a patsy by telling him that it's all
part of an audition for reality TV. Well done throughout, and sure to be noticed.
After all, Keanu Reeves has already expressed interest in playing Wells."
Publishers
Weekly:
"Berenson, a New York Times correspondent since 1999 who covered the occupation
of Iraq, deftly employs the classic staples of spy fiction in his debut novel
self-serving bureaucrats, a beautiful co-worker love interest and an on-the-run
hero suspected of being a traitor - then mixes in current terror tropes: car
bombs, smuggled nuclear material, and bio-weapons... Mounting suspense, a believable
scenario and a final twist add up to a compelling tale of frightening possibilities.
It's not for the squeamish, though: the torture sequences and bombing descriptions
are graphic and chillingly real."
The
Kansas City Star:
On the day the planes flew into the World Trade Center, undercover CIA agent John Wells, watching the jubilation on the part of those around him from his posting deep inside al-Qaida, vowed that such a thing would never happen again as long as he was alive.
His
pledge is about to be put to the test, as Osama bin Laden's
deputy, Ayman al-Zawahiri, plans another attack on the United
States. Without telling Wells any details, al-Zawahiri orders
the American back home to await further instructions. Wells
knows that his only chance to prevent the attack is to continue
to masquerade as a willing martyr until he learns what he
needs to do to stop the carnage.
He's convincing;
so much so that his bosses at the CIA wonder if he has gone
native.” After all, he didn't warn them about 9/11
(forget that he didn't know about it ahead of time), he hasn't
been in touch since he penetrated al-Qaida, he has become
a Muslim, and instead of checking in upon arriving in the
States, he first visited his ex-wife and son.
One
of the more hard-nosed bureaucrats wants to take him in immediately,
while his former handler wants to wait. Wells senses the
lack of trust and takes off, knowing that he's the country's
only hope. When he finally learns what al-Zawahiri has in
mind, it is a race to the end as the CIA closes in. New
York Times reporter Alex Berenson's experience covering the Middle East adds authenticity to the fictions of The Faithful Spy (344 pages; Random House; $24.95). This nail-biter is the best spy thriller I've
read in a long, long while. |